Psychic Wounds Drive Characters to Make Misjudgments and That’s Good for the Plot

by Marylee MacDonald in Characters, For Writers Doing Revisions

Characters with psychic wounds engage our sympathies. In this post I’m going to talk about the benefits of loading your characters down with problems, including attitudes toward life caused by childhood psychic wounds.

My purpose is not to play amateur psychologist. Save that for the self-help books. Instead, I’m going to show how psychic wounds cause characters to make misjudgments. These misjudgments are great for building complexity into the character’s inner and outer life.


Psychic wounds from childhood spill over into adult life. Understanding your characters' early losses and coping mechanisms can help you create lifelike protagonists. The main thing to ask yourself is this: How did their early psychic wound cause them to make misjudgments in the "now" of the novel.

What Is A Psychic Wound?

A psychic wound is a psychological blow that strikes a character in childhood. One of the most common psychic wounds in literature is that of the orphaned child. Searing loss from the death of a beloved parent is something a person in real life attempts to work out during adolescence, young adulthood, and even older adulthood.

Without a parent’s guidance and limit-setting, adolescents struggle to define themselves. Death causes real people to lose the backboard against which they might have bounced the ball. (Look at the number of self-help books on motherless and fatherless daughters, in particular.)

Women are not the only ones affected by early trauma. Consider the young man whose father has died of a heart attack at 32. How does that young man feel on his 32nd birthday? Strangely exposed.

How Psychic Wounds Change Us

If we look at real people, we know that a parent’s death in early childhood strips away a child’s sense of safety. Anger, sadness, and confusion fill the void.

A parent’s death during adolescence–that critical time in which our life-task is to define who we will be when we grow up–gives us a gut punch that can haunt us the rest of our lives. So, too, the rupture of a divorce, the trauma of alcoholism, or a childhood scarred by abuse. All leave particular kinds of psychic wounds. The same goes for childhoods affected by racism, hunger, war, and economic deprivation.

All the above events leave scars. In a sense, from the moment of trauma forward, the individual’s burning desire may be to keep “the bad thing” from ever happening again. Much as tracks are burned into a CD, early trauma sears the “bad thing” into the amygdala, the primitive survival center of the brain. Those tracks are virtually impossible to erase. With a lot of therapy, most people can manage the most damaging effects, but I don’t believe we can ever wipe the slate clean.

How Have Writers Made Use of Psychic Wounds?

In 18th and 19th-century literature, protagonists were often orphans. Think of Huckleberry Finn, David Copperfield and Jane Eyre, for instance. In all these novels the authors tracked the progress of a young person growing through adolescence without a parent’s guidance. The protagonists had to figure out what values they would live by. Their economic circumstances were precarious.

Psychic wounds

Early traumas that cause psychic wounds may not be fully accessible to our memories. The younger we were, the less we recall, and we especially may not recall events accurately. A child is looking up at adult actions, but not always with a complete understanding. Nevertheless, the child’s “truth” is seared into the soul and becomes a pivot point for how that person copes with the world.

A parent’s early death, while a child is powerless and has an incomplete understanding of how to recover from such a wound, makes it necessary for the adolescent–and then the adult–to revisit this hurt again and again.

Likability and Psychic Wounds

In real life, how do we feel about our friends who slide through life unscathed? Secretly envious. Am I right?

Psychic wounds, on the other hand, induce sympathy. If a person in real life behaves badly, we cut them some slack. Well, it’s understandable that he’s in the Principal’s office again. He just lost his father. We understand that an abandoned child can have problems with trust and intimacy, and that when an orphan does connect with either a friend or lover, the relationship is especially meaningful.

The likability of Diana Gabaldon’s (from the Outlander series) two protagonists, Claire and Jamie, partly arises from their vulnerability as orphans. We understand that, essentially, they have no one to fall back on. In Jamie’s case, even the powerful MacDougal clan cannot make up for his losses.

James Agee’s A Death In the Family and Carolyn Chute’s The Beans of Egypt, Maine provide two examples of writers who’ve mined psychic wounds for what they have to say about the human condition. Anthony Doerr’s All The Light We Cannot See features two semi-orphaned protagonists, and both win our hearts.

Characters Making Choices

When a story or novel opens, we writers must strive to create an immediate bond between the reader and the protagonist. If we can enlist readers’ sympathies, we’ll create a bond. The bond occurs if we can hint at, or explicitly show, the protagonist’s vulnerability.

Fiction is all about characters who stand at crossroads. Because of psychic wounds, characters often make the wrong choice. Why don’t they do the logical, sensible thing, readers might ask? Often, it’s because the character is trying to avoid the “bad thing” that happened in the past. In a sense, the novel becomes a stage upon which a wounded character can “work out” the baggage of the past.

Strategies to Bring Psychic Wounds Into the Novel

Writers are often tempted to go into a flashback and dramatize the moment of trauma or loss, but any time you skip from the present, ongoing action of the novel and go back to the past, you risk losing the reader. That’s because what’s past is past, and the reader wants to find out what’s going to happen right now.

So try this:

Dramatize (meaning put in scene) moments when the character deviates from normal behavior. A young woman turns away from a proposal from a man she clearly loves (fear of intimacy). Or, a man obsessively keeps track of pennies, much to the annoyance of his dining companions (the result of losing everything in a war).

Put the character under more and more pressure. Expose their vulnerability. The young woman may get away with delaying a marriage, but eventually, push will come to shove, and she will be forced to take a leap into trust, or not. The man who lived through war may find himself increasingly the butt of jokes until the day that his penny-saving behavior either proves that he was wise to be cautious (his friends are proven wrong) or a burglar steals the penny jar on his bureau and forces him to realize that his friends are “there for him.”

If you haven’t thought about a psychic wound for your character, consider stitching one into the preceding chapters. Think about how the climax would be different–and even more intense–if the “moment of truth” forced the character to deal with her or his deepest vulnerability.

If you can give a character a psychic wound, and then have the coping mechanisms around that wound be the very thing the ongoing action of the story forces her or him to change, you will discover the happy marriage between past and present that makes a story rich.


11 Responses to “Psychic Wounds Drive Characters to Make Misjudgments and That’s Good for the Plot”

  1. This is such a fascinating article and definitely something I would like to consider referring to again. Thank you for sharing. 🙂

    • Hi Marje,
      Thanks for the comment. The key concept is that the psychic wound ought to happen in childhood or during the teen years. We all have traumas as adults, but that’s not quite the same thing as a trauma that leaves a scar on a child’s psyche. Good luck with your writing.

  2. Nancy Roe says:

    Thanks for the insight!


    The description of psychic wound is quite interesting and useful to describe the character..Thanks for the knowledge..

  4. Hi Marylee

    Right now, I’m toying with a bit of fan fiction based on the ITV series POIROT.

    While he wasn’t permitted a love-story / marriage according to the novels, I’m giving Poirot a tragic love story as part of his background. (Love, marriage, baby on the way, tragedy). This deep loss could explain his fastidiously meticulous behaviors.

    It’s been known that people who’ve suffered a loss over which they have no control exhibit ‘control’ issues to compensate, in some way, for what they had no ability to change.

    I’ve vaguely heard of the term “Psychic wounds” before. However, I never knew what it meant. Thanks for the clarification.

    • I probably should write a post about later-in-life wounds, things that might cause PTSD-like symptoms. Poirot is one of my favorite characters, and oddly, I knew someone very much like him–fastidious in the extreme. That read person’s trauma was based on his rich family having been sent into exile when he was at a very young age. He went from wealth to poverty overnight. You might want to think about moving your fictional Poirot’s trauma to an even earlier period of life.

  5. Great idea since the death of Bruce Wayne’s parents when he was a child and the death of Jason Todd affected his way of fighting crime as Batman.

  6. Bethany Reid says:

    Marylee — I have been working on a novel about a woman who (I worried) needed some trauma in childhood, that “ghost” or psychic wound from the past that she is still trying to heal. I thought of her parents as rather perfect and could never see them as anything but loving and nurturing of their only child, a late-life child. But your post opened my eyes — her father dies when she is only ten — and this is PLENTY of loss. By the time of the novel, when she has children of her own, her mother has also passed. I just have to mine the vein that is already there. Thank you!

    • Hi Bethany,
      You are absolutely correct about “plenty of loss.” What’s good is that readers will bring their own understanding to the page. It means you don’t have to go into laborious detail on backstory. Just paint it in with a broad brush and maybe with one or two poignant moments.